An Archive of Replication Attempts in Experimental Psychology

[What's New]
Show me postings from the past


Restrict to Specific Topics [Hide Options]
Toggle All Attention Behavior Genetics Development: Cognitive Development: Perception Development: Social JDM Language Learning Memory
Perception Performance Personality Problem Solving Psychometrics and IQ Psychopathology/Clinical Social Cognition Social Psychology Thinking
Include class projects


If you wish to submit details of your own replication attempt, you need to log in.

This Chart View provides an overview of each posting in the current group. To see the details of any one article, click on the View More Details of Posting link in the Title column.

Title Reference to Original Report of Finding Brief Statement of Original Result Type of Replication AttemptedResult TypeDifference? Number of SubjectsNumber of Subjects in Original Study Year in which Replication Attempt was MadeName of Investigators Tags How to Cite this Posting
On the (non)persuasive influence of a brain image View More Details of Posting!McCabe, D. P., & Castel, A. D. (2008). Seeing is believing: The effect of brain images on judgments of scientific reasoning. Cognition, 107(1), 343-352. View Article People agree more with the conclusions of a scientific news article when it is accompanied by a picture of the brain. Highly Direct ReplicationFailure to Replicate Same Direction, .07 1971 JDM
Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel View More Details of Posting!McCabe, D.P., & Castel, A.D. (2008). Seeing is believing: The effect of brain images on judgments of scientific reasoning. The presence of a brain image increased ratings of agreement with a news article’s conclusions, and the presence of criticism had no effect. The presence of a brain image did not affect ratings of the appropriateness of the title, but the presence of criticism decreased ratings of the title. Highly Direct ReplicationFailure to Replicate Opposite Direction, .40 99 108 2014Bogdan Kostic, Cory DerringerJDM View

APA Style

Bogdan Kostic, Cory Derringer. Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel. (2014, April 25). Retrieved 19:25, June 28, 2017 from http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MTg1

MLA Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel" Bogdan Kostic, Cory Derringer. 25 Apr 2014 15:45 28 Jun 2017, 19:25 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MTg1>

MHRA Style

'Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel', Bogdan Kostic, Cory Derringer, , 25 April 2014 15:45 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MTg1> [accessed 28 June 2017]

Chicago Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel", Bogdan Kostic, Cory Derringer, , http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MTg1 (accessed June 28, 2017)

CBE/CSE Style

Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel [Internet]. Bogdan Kostic, Cory Derringer; 2014 Apr 25, 15:45 [cited 2017 Jun 28]. Available from: http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MTg1
Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp1 View More Details of Posting!McCabe, D. P., & Castel, A. D. (2008). Seeing is believing: The effect of brain images on judgments of scientific reasoning. Cognition, 107(1), 343-352. When brain image is included to fictional articles summarizing cognitive neuroscience research, people agree with its scientific reasoning better than when either bar graph or no image is included. Highly Direct ReplicationFailure to Replicate No 90 156 2014Aya Murayama, Asako MiuraJDM View

APA Style

Aya Murayama, Asako Miura. Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp1. (2015, January 04). Retrieved 19:25, June 28, 2017 from http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA3

MLA Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp1" Aya Murayama, Asako Miura. 04 Jan 2015 21:02 28 Jun 2017, 19:25 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA3>

MHRA Style

'Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp1', Aya Murayama, Asako Miura, , 04 January 2015 21:02 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA3> [accessed 28 June 2017]

Chicago Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp1", Aya Murayama, Asako Miura, , http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA3 (accessed June 28, 2017)

CBE/CSE Style

Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp1 [Internet]. Aya Murayama, Asako Miura; 2015 Jan 04, 21:02 [cited 2017 Jun 28]. Available from: http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA3
Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp2 View More Details of Posting!McCabe, D. P., & Castel, A. D. (2008). Seeing is believing: The effect of brain images on judgments of scientific reasoning. Cognition, 107(1), 343-352. People who read articles accompanied by brain images agree with its scientific reasoning more than when these articles were accompanied by topographical maps of brain activation. Highly Direct ReplicationFailure to Replicate No 83 128 2014Aya Murayama & Asako MiuraJDM View

APA Style

Aya Murayama & Asako Miura. Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp2. (2015, January 04). Retrieved 19:25, June 28, 2017 from http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA4

MLA Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp2" Aya Murayama & Asako Miura. 04 Jan 2015 21:17 28 Jun 2017, 19:25 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA4>

MHRA Style

'Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp2', Aya Murayama & Asako Miura, , 04 January 2015 21:17 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA4> [accessed 28 June 2017]

Chicago Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp2", Aya Murayama & Asako Miura, , http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA4 (accessed June 28, 2017)

CBE/CSE Style

Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp2 [Internet]. Aya Murayama & Asako Miura; 2015 Jan 04, 21:17 [cited 2017 Jun 28]. Available from: http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA4
Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp3 View More Details of Posting!McCabe, D. P., & Castel, A. D. (2008). Seeing is believing: The effect of brain images on judgments of scientific reasoning. Cognition, 107(1), 343-352. The original results showed that the effect of brain image was generalized to actual news article,that people who read BBC news article accompanied with brain image agreed with the statement "the title, Brain Scans Can Detect Criminals, is a good summary of the results?" more than people who read the same article without any images. The result also showed a critical comment from professionals increased disagreement with the conclusion of the article. Highly Direct ReplicationFailure to Replicate Not Applicable 88 108 2014Aya Murayama & Asako MiuraJDM View

APA Style

Aya Murayama & Asako Miura. Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp3. (2015, January 04). Retrieved 19:25, June 28, 2017 from http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA5

MLA Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp3" Aya Murayama & Asako Miura. 04 Jan 2015 21:51 28 Jun 2017, 19:25 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA5>

MHRA Style

'Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp3', Aya Murayama & Asako Miura, , 04 January 2015 21:51 <http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA5> [accessed 28 June 2017]

Chicago Style

"Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp3", Aya Murayama & Asako Miura, , http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA5 (accessed June 28, 2017)

CBE/CSE Style

Failure to replicate McCabe & Castel (2008), Exp3 [Internet]. Aya Murayama & Asako Miura; 2015 Jan 04, 21:51 [cited 2017 Jun 28]. Available from: http://www.PsychFileDrawer.org/replication.php?attempt=MjA5

Are you posting an unpublished replication attempt that you conducted yourself, or noting a published replication attempt?

Post Unpublished
Post Published